Tuesday, April 9, 2024

Latest Posts

Why Did Trump Pull Out Of The Iran Nuclear Deal

The Us Withdrawal From The Iran Deal: One Year On

Why Trump was right to pull out of Iran nuclear deal

On 8 May last year, US President Donald J. Trump announced that the United States would pull out of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action , which sets limits on Irans nuclear programme to ensure that it cannot produce nuclear weapons. Despite the US withdrawal, the JCPOA remains in force it is a multilateral agreement to which seven of the original eight parties still adhere.

When they arrived at the agreement in July 2015, the parties to it were Iran, the USA, China, Russia, France, Germany, the United Kingdom and the European Union. A few days after the JCPOA was agreed, it was endorsed by the United Nations Security Council.

The JCPOA limits Irans uranium enrichment programme until 2030 and contains monitoring and transparency measures that will remain in place long after that date. Along with other international experts, SIPRIs assessment from the outset has been that the agreement is technically sound with robust verification procedures.The International Atomic Energy Agency is responsible for monitoring Irans JCPOA implementation. It has consistently found that Iran is fully living up to its undertakings. In short, well-crafted and properly implemented, the JCPOA closes off Irans pathway to nuclear weapons, should it decide to go in that direction.

Political Influences And Decisions

Some reports suggest that Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu‘s “Iran Lied” presentation influenced the withdrawal. A little more than a week after Netanyahu’s presentation, Trump announced that the U.S. would withdraw from the deal. He announced the withdrawal during a speech at the White House on May 8, 2018, saying, “the heart of the Iran deal was a giant fiction: that a murderous regime desired only a peaceful nuclear energy program.” Trump added that there was “definitive proof that this Iranian promise was a lie. Last week, Israel published intelligence documents long concealed by Iran conclusively showing the Iranian regime and its history of pursuing nuclear weapons.” According to Trump’s secretary of stateMike Pompeo and the International Atomic Energy Agency, the agency tasked with verifying and monitoring Iran’s compliance with the JCPOA, Iran has been in compliance with the JCPOA and there is no evidence otherwise. According to David Makovsky, a Middle East scholar at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, Iran was not in compliance, because under the deal’s terms Iran was supposed to reveal all of its research into nuclear weapons, and that based on Netanyahu’s evidence, it seems clear that they did not.

Role of George Nader

Role of John Bolton

Resignation of the special representative

  • The Democratic Party criticized Trump’s decision to withdraw.
  • Former president Barack Obama said “the deal was working and it was in US interests.”
  • France:
  • Read More On The Relations Between Asia And The Us

    As Mr. Trump abandoned one diplomatic project, he accelerated another announcing that Mr. Pompeo was flying to Pyongyang, the capital of North Korea, to continue discussions with Mr. Kim about the upcoming summit meeting. He expressed hope that three Americans who are detained in the North would be released soon.

    The message to North Korea, Mr. Bolton told reporters, is the president wants a real deal.

    He rejected the suggestion that the United States could not be trusted to keep its agreements when political winds change. Any nation reserves the right to correct a past mistake, Mr. Bolton said, citing President George W. Bushs decision to withdraw from the Antiballistic Missile Treaty in 2001.

    Also Check: What’s New With President Trump

    President Announces Pullout From Deal Aimed At Curbing Tehrans Nuclear Activity Calling It Horrible

    Listen to article

    WASHINGTONThe U.S. is exiting the Iranian nuclear accord, President Donald Trump said Tuesday, dismantling his predecessors most prominent foreign-policy initiative and bucking the appeals of some of Americas closest allies.

    Speaking in the Diplomatic Room of the White House, Mr. Trump delivered harsh words about the 2015 deal to curb and monitor Irans nuclear activity, calling it horrible, one-sided and disastrous. The president said he planned to institute sanctions against Iran, and said the U.S. would sanction any nation that helps Tehran pursue nuclear weapons, as well as U.S. and foreign companies and banks that continue to do business with the country.

    Iran Nuclear Deal: Why Has Trump Withdrawn Us From It And Why Does It Matter

    What is the Iran nuclear deal and why has Donald Trump pulled out ...

    Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile

    US President Donald Trump has fulfilled an election campaign promise to pull out of the landmark 2015 nuclear deal agreed between Iran and world powers, an agreement former Secretary of State John Kerry said made the world a safer place.

    Mr Trump said the Obama-era legislation would be scrapped on Tuesday, calling the deal decaying and rotten.

    The US will not be held hostage to nuclear blackmail or allow a regime that chants Death to America to gain nuclear weapons, he said from the White House in a long-expected announcement.

    The administration intends to reinstate severe sanctions against the Islamic Republic.

    Recommended Reading: Is Trump Trying To Cut Social Security And Medicare

    On A Collision Course

    Analysis by Jonathan Marcus, BBC defence and diplomatic correspondent

    With a stroke of his pen President Trump has jeopardised the one agreement – good or bad -that seeks to constrain Iran’s nuclear ambitions.

    He launched a scathing assault on the deal and its deficiencies, but he offered no alternative policy to put in its place.

    He has put US diplomacy on a collision course with some of Washington’s closest allies.

    And some fear that he may have brought a new and catastrophic regional war in the Middle East that much closer.

    Us Pulls Out Of Iran Nuclear Deal: Dw’s Clare Richardson Political Analyst Markus Kaim

    To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

    How world leaders reacted

    French President Emmanuel Macron tweeted shortly after Trump’s announcement that “France, Germany and the UK regret the US decision” to leave the deal. He said that the remaining parties will work on addressing Iran’s “ballistic activity” as well as ensuring stability in the Middle East in “Syria, Yemen and Iraq.”

    Germany, the UK and France reaffirmed their commitment to the deal and urged for the US not to obstruct other countries as they attempt to implement the deal, according to a joint statement provided by British Prime Minister Theresa May’s office. May, Macron and German Chancellor Anglea Merkel spoke by telephone shortly before Trump’s speech.

    The European Union’s top diplomat, Federica Mogherini, called on the international community to stick with the deal, saying that the EU is “determined to preserve it.” She noted that she was “particularly worried” by Trump’s announcement of new sanctions against Iran.

    Read more:

    In a rare move, former US President Barack Obama whose administration brokered the deal criticized his successor’s decision to leave the deal. He said Trump’s move was a “serious mistake” and emphasized that independent experts, US officials and EU allies agree the deal is working.

    Read Also: How Do You Contact Donald Trump

    New Faces In The Room

    Mr Trump had made motions toward, and then backed away from, formally pulling out of the Iran deal several times over the first year of his presidency.

    He was reportedly counselled against abandoning the agreement by senior advisers in his administration, including Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, National Security Advisor HR McMaster and Secretary of Defence James Mattis.

    Mr Mattis is the only man left standing, and his influence appears to be waning. The other two have been replaced by Mike Pompeo and John Bolton, respectively, and both are considered Iran hawks.

    Where once the president may have been counselled to be cautious in abandoning US commitments to Iran, this time his instincts – an innate distrust of multilateralism in general and Iran in particular – appear to have been enthusiastically supported.

    After 15 months Mr Trump has built a foreign policy team that is largely on the same page – his page.

    What Trump Just Did To The Iran Nuclear Deal

    Donald Trump pulls US out of ‘disastrous’ Iran nuclear deal | ITV News

    Prior to the Iran deal, the P5+1 had imposed a dizzying and complex set of international sanctions on Iran as punishment for its nuclear development. The basic gist of the deal was that the sanctions would be lifted in exchange for Iran agreeing to several serious restrictions on its nuclear development. Among the most important, the deal called for:

    • Reducing Irans stockpile of enriched uranium by 97 percent, and banning them from possessing any uranium potent enough that it could be used to fuel a bomb
    • Capping its number of nuclear centrifuges, devices used to enrich uranium, at roughly 5,000 and only permitting it to use old, outdated, and slow centrifuges
    • Stopping Iran from operating its Arak facility used to make plutonium that could fuel a bomb
    • Permitting wide-ranging and intrusive IAEA inspections designed to verify that Iran isnt cheating on any portion of the deal

    These provisions, taken together, make it functionally impossible for Iran to acquire a nuclear weapon so long as they are in place. And the IAEA has repeatedly confirmed that Iran is complying with all of its obligations under the deal.

    With the deal in place, it would be extremely difficult for Iran to build the bomb without being detected and there would be a time frame that would allow the international community to respond, James Acton, director of the Carnegie Endowments Nuclear Policy Program, tells me.

    But the deal isnt dead, at least not yet.

    Don’t Miss: Where Can I Get Trump Signs

    When Will The Sanctions Restart

    The US Treasury said economic sanctions would not be reimposed on Iran immediately, but would be subject to 90-day and 180-day wind-down periods.

    In a statement on its website, it said sanctions would be reimposed on the industries mentioned in the 2015 deal, including Iran’s oil sector, aircraft exports, precious metals trade, and Iranian government attempts to buy US dollar banknotes.

    US National Security Advisor John Bolton is reported as saying that European companies doing business with Iran will have to finish within six months or face US sanctions.

    Us Deployment To Middle East

    Under the 2015 deal, Iran restricted the capacity of its uranium enrichment program – widely seen as a route to developing a nuclear weapon – in exchange for a lifting of most international sanctions. U.N. nuclear inspectors have repeatedly verified Iranian compliance with the accord.

    Iran has denied ever pursuing a nuclear weapons program.

    The other signatories to the deal – European powers Germany, France and Britain – and Russia and China remain committed to it. The EU has been looking into ways of preserving its economic benefits that Iran says must stay or it could abandon the deal.

    The Trump administration is now deploying a carrier strike group and bombers to the Middle East in response to troubling indications and warnings from Iran and to show the United States will retaliate with unrelenting force to any attack, U.S. national security adviser John Bolton said on Sunday.

    Bolton – who has spearheaded an increasingly hawkish U.S. policy on Iran – said the decision, which could exacerbate tensions between the two countries, was meant to send a clear and unmistakable message of U.S. resolve to Tehran.

    U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo also issued a warning to the Islamic Republic on Sunday.

    It is absolutely the case that we have seen escalatory actions from the Iranians and it is equally the case that we will hold the Iranians accountable for attacks on American interests, Pompeo told reporters aboard a flight en route to an Arctic Council meeting in Finland.

    Recommended Reading: Is Trump Speaking On Tv Tonight

    What Did Iran Agree To

    Nuclear restrictions. Iran agreed not to produce either the highly enriched uranium or the plutonium that could be used in a nuclear weapon. It also took steps to ensure that its Fordow, Natanz, and Arak facilities pursued only civilian work, including medical and industrial research.

    The accord limits the numbers and types of centrifuges Iran can operate, the level of its enrichment, as well as the size of its stockpile of enriched uranium.

    Monitoring and verification. Iran agreed to eventually implement a protocol that would allow inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency , the United Nations nuclear watchdog, unfettered access to its nuclear facilities and potentially to undeclared sites. Inspections are intended to guard against the possibility that Iran could develop nuclear arms in secret, as it has allegedly attempted before. The IAEA has issued quarterly reports to its board of governors and the UN Security Council on Irans implementation of its nuclear commitments.

    A body known as the Joint Commission, which includes representatives of all the negotiating parties, monitors implementation of the agreement and resolves disputes that may arise. A majority vote by its members can gain IAEA inspectors access to suspicious, undeclared sites. The body also oversees the transfer of nuclear-related or dual-use materials.

    Iran To Restart Some Nuclear Activity In Response To Us Withdrawal From Nuclear Deal

    Nuclear deal: Iran says Trump sending âdangerous messageâ

    4 Min Read

    GENEVA – Iran will restart part of its halted nuclear program in response to the U.S. withdrawal from a landmark 2015 nuclear deal but does not itself plan to pull out of the agreement, the state-run IRIB news agency reported on Monday.

    Citing a source close to an official commission which oversees the nuclear deal, IRIB reported that President Hassan Rouhani would announce that Iran would reduce some of its minor and general commitments under the deal on May 8 – exactly one year after U.S. President Donald Trump announced the U.S. pullout.

    Trump subsequently reimposed tough sanctions on Iran, including on its lifeblood oil exports with the stated intent of reducing them to zero and starving Irans economy.

    The Islamic Republic of Iran in reaction to the exit of America from the nuclear deal and the bad promises of European countries in carrying out their obligations will restart a part of the nuclear activities which were stopped under the framework of the nuclear deal, the source said, according to IRIB.

    Similarly, the semi-official Iranian Students News Agency reported that Iran on Wednesday will announce reciprocal actions to the U.S. withdrawal from the nuclear deal, quoting knowledgeable sources.

    Some European Union leaders had been unofficially told of Irans decision, the report said.

    The United States acted on Friday to force Iran to stop producing low-enriched uranium and expanding its only nuclear power plant.

    Read Also: Do Farmers Still Support Trump

    A Worthless Withdrawal: Two Years Since President Trump Abandoned The Jcpoa

    May 8 marked two years since President Trump formally withdrew from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action , better known as the Iran nuclear deal, while maintaining that t is the policy of the United States that Iran be denied a nuclear weapon and intercontinental ballistic missiles. Since then, the Trump Administration unilaterally re-imposed crippling sanctions on Iran and antagonized our allies by forcing them to comply or risk financial isolation. They have also wasted valuable time trying to disassemble the Iran nuclear deal rather than pursuing negotiations to address its concerns. Now, the United States is scrambling to respond to the impending end of a United Nations arms embargo linked to the nuclear deal.

    In retaliation for the Trump Administrations decision to leave the JCPOA, Iran incrementally stepped back from compliance with the deal one year later beginning in May 2019 and our allies have resisted calls to punish Iran over its legitimate grievances. Irans proximity to a nuclear weapon capability has gradually increased due to the Trump Administrations policies, and Iran is now roughly six months away from having enough weapons-grade fissile material for a nuclear bomb. When President Trump took office, Iran was about a year from that milestone. As a whole, the Trump Administrations withdrawal from the JCPOA and maximum pressure strategy has gotten the United States no closer to its stated goals.

    Trump Says Us To Leave Key Nuclear Arms Treaty With Russia

    The Trump administration moved Friday to withdraw from a key missile treaty with Russia that has formed a cornerstone of nuclear arms control efforts for decades, accusing President Vladimir Putin’s government of breaching the pact and raising fears of a new Cold War-style arms race with Moscow.

    President Donald Trump, announcing the U.S. intent to withdraw from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, said Russia had been violating the agreement “with impunity.”

    “We cannot be the only country in the world unilaterally bound by this treaty, or any other,” Trump said in a statement.

    His tough words for Russia were echoed by Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, who said the U.S. would formally notify Moscow on Saturday that the U.S. will withdraw. Pompeo said Russia was in “material breach” of the pact and that NATO allies had “stood with us in our mission to uphold the rule of law and protect our people.”

    “We provided Russia an ample window of time to mend its ways and for Russia to honor its commitment,” Pompeo said. “Tomorrow that time runs out.”

    The 1987 treaty bans deployment and required the destruction of ground-based missiles with a range of between 500 and 5,500 kilometers or 310 to 3,410 miles whose presence in Europe became a point of crisis during the Cold War. Signed by President Ronald Reagan and Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev, the pact has been viewed for decades as a model for arms control agreements between major powers.

    Recommended Reading: Is The Trump Marriage In Trouble

    Latest Posts

    Popular Articles