Insurance Company Profits Have Soared While Families Pay More
Across all lines of business, insurance companiesprofit margin has increased in recent years, shooting up from about 1 percent in 2016 to 3 percent in 2019. Insurance company profits have been boosted by a number of factors, including the expansion of companies business in Medicare Advantage and Medicaid and the benefits of relatively unchecked vertical consolidation with other firms in the health care industry. In years to come, insurance companies stand to benefit if Trump follows through on his executive order to shift more Medicare beneficiaries into private plans, to the detriment of beneficiaries access to providers.
While the pandemic has depressed economic activity this year in most industries, insurance companies profitability to date has topped last years. Medical spending is down dramatically in 2020 due to deferred care during the pandemic, boosting companies net income above expectations. Thanks to the ACAs medical loss ratio requirement, insurers will be required to return excess premiums to consumers if medical spending for the year is below what they anticipated. Meanwhile, the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and state regulators have encouraged or required insurers to waive or discount premiums and cost sharing in order to assist consumers and meet medical loss requirements.
We Didnt Have A Free Market Before Obamacare
A: You know, I looked at that. I looked at it very seriously. Some peopledont agree with me on this: I want everyone to have coverage. I love the free market, but we never had a free market. Even before ObamaCare, it wasnt really free market.As an example, in New York, when I wanted to bid out my health insurance, we had boundaries. I could only go in New York. If I wanted to bid it out to a company from California or New Jersey, anywhereyou get no bids.
Q: But the single payer, yourenot interested anymore?
A: No. No, these are different times. And over the years, you are going to change your attitudes. Youre going to learn things and youre going to change. And I have evolved on that issue. I have evolved on numerous issues.
The Trump Administrations Discreet Obamacare Repeal Agenda
The ACA was supposed to be a step, the most significant in a generation, toward a system in which Americans would not be left on the hook for tens of thousands of dollars in medical bills. It created, for the first time, a federal standard for what constituted major medical insurance. The law sought to make preexisting conditions a relic, requiring health insurers to cover everybody at the same price and to provide a comprehensive set of benefits.
This series was made possible through a collaboration with the Center for Public Integrity, a DC-based nonprofit newsroom. Get updates on their work. You can also support Vox with a financial contribution. Learn more.
To help achieve its goal of near-universal coverage, it created a single, well-regulated market for individuals to buy health insurance if they dont get it through their work. The law contained a mandate that every person purchase ACA-compliant insurance or pay a penalty, and provided tax subsidies to make health insurance more affordable.
But Obama health officials did not believe they had the authority to ban skimpy, short-term plans. Instead, the Obama administration released regulations that prohibited noncompliant plans from being issued for longer than three months. The goal was to whittle down the non-Obamacare market as much as possible and divert people into the new insurance exchanges where ACA-compliant plans were being sold.
Don’t Miss: What Is Trump’s Insurance Plan
Where Biden And Trump Stand On 11 Key Healthcare Issues
From COVID-19 to the state of the Affordable Care Act, the presidential candidates offer contrasting visions for the future of healthcare in the United States.
President Donald Trump and Democratic challenger Joe Biden have dramatically different visions for the future of healthcare policy in the United States.
Healthcare, and specifically access to affordable care, has been a topic of fierce debate in recent presidential elections, and remains top of mind for voters this year, in part, due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
In fact, 29 percent of Americans say healthcare, not the economy, is the most important issue to them, according to a recent Economist and YouGov poll.
With early voting already underway in some states, Healthline spoke with nonpartisan healthcare policy experts to compare where each presidential candidate stands on so voters can make the most informed decision possible when casting their ballot in this crucial election.
The Holes In Americas Health System Have Gotten Bigger Under Trump
The long-term future of short-term plans will ultimately be determined by the 2020 presidential election.
Donald Trump believes he has met his promise to roll back Obamacare and make cheaper health insurance more available. Presumptive Democratic nominee Joe Biden, on the other hand, is pledging to expand the governments role in guaranteeing quality health coverage and reverse Trumps sabotage of the health care law. He wants to set up a new public option that would compete directly with private plans, both ACA-compliant and not. He said in March that the short-term health insurance plans are called junk plans for a reason.
President Trumps Administration has consistently sought to convey these junk plans as legitimate alternatives to high-quality plans meeting Obamacares consumer protections, Biden said in a statement. They are not.
Some states have already intervened to stop Trumps expansion of short-term plans. Some, like California, banned their sale entirely. Others, like Colorado, imposed strict rules that ended up discouraging short-term plans from continuing to sell in their state, despite the efforts of the Trump administration. Meanwhile, some, like Pennsylvania, are limited by state statute in how much they can do to restrict short-term plans, but the mere presence of an aggressive regulator can dissuade insurers from entering the market.
The general attitude taken, Linke Young says, is do whatever you want we dont care.
You May Like: How Many Votes Did Trump Get In Florida
The Costs Of Trumpcare 10
- According to the Congressional Budget Office, the CBO and JCT estimate that enacting the American Health Care Act would reduce federal deficits by $337 billion over the coming decade and increase the number of people who are uninsured by 24 million in 2026 relative to current law.
- According to the Congressional Budget Office, the CBO and JCT estimate that enacting the American Health Care Act would reduce federal deficits by $119 billion over the coming decade and increase the number of people who are uninsured by 23 million in 2026 relative to current law.
- MOST RECENT: According to the Congressional Budget Office, the plan in its current form saves $321 billion over the decade. However, it did does by leaving 49 million without coverage by 2026 . The cost and uninsured rate are subject to change based on changes to the bill. See a breakdown of the costs here.
The CBO report done after the Amendment shows 1 million less uninsured and about $200 billion in less in savings. See the Key Facts From the May 2017 CBO Report on TrumpCare . UPDATE: We will do some key facts from the Senate bill soon.
TIP: That CBO scoring is subject to change, the plan has been revised since it was scored. The passed bill was not scored at the time of passing.
A Trump Executive Order Ended Subsidies For Obamacare Tax Credits
Trump signed an executive order in October 2017, eliminating subsidies provided to help people pay for their health insurance.
Under Obamacare, tax credits were available to people who earn up to 250% of the federal poverty level . These tax-credit subsidies help cover the cost of annual deductibles in Obamacare marketplace plans.
The executive order signed by Trump did away with those subsidies.
You May Like: Where And When Is Trump’s Next Rally
Back To The Future: Trumps History Of Promising A Health Plan That Never Comes
By Victoria KnightAugust 13, 2020
We encourage organizations to republish our content, free of charge. Heres what we ask:
You must credit us as the original publisher, with a hyperlink to our khn.org site. If possible, please include the original author and Kaiser Health News in the byline. Please preserve the hyperlinks in the story.
Have questions? Let us know at
Trumps Moves On Health Care
President Trump campaigned and entered office with the pledge to repeal and replace the ACA. In his own words, there would be a really great HealthCare Plan with far lower premiums & deductibles right after the election.
Since 2016, Congress has made little headway besides eliminating the ACAs penalty for not carrying insurance. This is the basis for the current lawsuit to be heard before the Supreme Court in November. The argument is that because Congress did away with the penalty, the individual mandate can no longer be constitutionally justified as a tax. As a result, the entire law should fall.
While Republicans have been unable to repeal the law, the Trump administration has taken a number of executive actions to limit its reach. In combination, these efforts have contributed to bringing the uninsured rate to 14% by 2019 from a low of 11% in 2016. This leaves millions of Americans without coverage and exposed to medical bills should they fall ill.
One of the major targets of the Trump administration has been reducing enrollment through the ACAs marketplaces. Here, the administration shortened the periods in which people are allowed to purchase insurance and drastically reduced funding for individuals who help consumers enroll in coverage as well as advertising. It also withheld subsidies to support low-income individuals with out-of-pocket costs, which also caused problems to insurers offering plans to those people.
Read Also: What Time Will President Trump
Criticism Of The Affordable Care Act
Critics of the ACA have pointed out that it represented an unprecedented expansion of federal power within the healthcare industry because it required all individuals to purchase a service whether they wanted to or not.
This aspect of the law was a major focus of debate, and it was challenged in the U.S. Supreme Court in 2012 by the National Federation of Independent Business. The court ruled in favor of the individual mandate as a constitutional exercise of the taxing authority of Congress, characterizing the penalties levied against the uninsured as a tax.
Patient Protection And Affordable Care Act
The first part of the comprehensive health care reform law enacted on March 23, 2010.
The law was amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act on March 30, 2010. The name â
The comprehensive health care reform law enacted in March 2010 .
The law provides numerous rights and protections that make health coverage more fair and easy to understand, along with subsidies to make it more affordable.
The law also expands the Medicaid program to cover more people with low incomes.
You May Like: Is President Trump Giving Away Money
The Cost Of Trumpcare
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget did a review of Trumps healthcare plan. The following article shows a breakdown of costs: MEASURING TRUMPS HEALTHCARE PLAN. The result is a cost of roughly $550 billion over ten years under conventional scoring and about $330 billion with dynamic scoring .
Note that this analysis does not include Mr. Trumps call to negotiate aggressively for Medicare drugs, a policy that is not listed on his website. He has previously claimed that $300 billion a year could be saved through negotiation, a claim we rated as false because Medicare will only spend an average of $111 billion each year on prescription drugs. Based on previous estimates by CBO, actual savings would likely be small or negligible.
NOTE: The plan assumes a full repeal of ObamaCare before replacing it. While this is possible given Trumps statements, it isnt necessarily what we would get from the future President Trump.
NOTE: Like him or hate him, Trump has mentioned some critical health policies like expanding Medicaid and debating drug costs for Medicare. These didnt make it into the Trump plan as written, but it would be a mistake to overlook the benefits of strategies like debating drug prices for Medicare.
|10-Year Estimates of Healthcare Reform to Make America Great Again
Taking Care Of Poor Sick People Isnt Single
TRUMP: Well, I like the mandate. I dont want people dying on the streets. The Republicanpeople, they dont want people dying on the streets, but sometimes theyll say Donald Trump wants single payer.
Q: Will people with pre-existing conditions be able to get insurance?
TRUMP: Yes.Now, the new plan is good. Its going to be inexpensive. Its going to be much better for the people at the bottom, people that dont have any money. Were going to take care of them through maybe concepts of Medicare. Now, some people would say, thatsnot a very Republican thing to say. Thats not single payer, by the way. Thats called heart. We gotta take care of people that cant take care of themselves.
Recommended Reading: How To Message Donald Trump
An Introduction To The Many Healthcare Bills Regulations And Ideas We Call Trumpcare
Below we explain different aspects of TrumpCare.
When people say TrumpCare they are essentially referring to healthcare changes made, attempted to be made, and/or pushed for under President Trump . This is sort of like how when people say ObamaCare they are referring to changes to the healthcare system under Obama, but especially the Affordable Care Act.
Changes and policy ideas under Trump that may be considered TrumpCare have included:
- PROPOSED: Trump has said he will pass executive orders to protect pre-existing conditions which would be repealed by the lawsuit backed by his administration along with the rest of the ACA. The specifics of these orders are not known yet.
- PROPOSED: The 2021 budget which includes almost $1 trillion in cuts to Medicaid and the ACA and $600 billion savings from Medicare.
- LIST OF GOALS: Tom Prices plans as shown on HHS,
- LIST OF GOALS: The TrumpCare as presented on DonaldJTrump.com , and
- LIST OF GOALS: Past promises Trump has made .
In other words, TrumpCare is a term that describes the ongoing health care reform effort under Donald Trump .
This is somewhat complicated by the fact that a repeal and replace plan did not pass Congress, and instead the Trump administration has been gradually reshaping the healthcare system using executive orders, legislative action, action in congress, and changes done via federal agencies like HHS.
Is This Like Trumpcare Promised On Trumps Website
Obviously, that isget rid of the mandates as it says on Trumps site, but that isntinsurance for everybody, and that isntnot letting them die in the streets.
In words, the plan doesnt include everything Trump promised by a long shot, but it does touch on many of his ideas as found on DonaldJTrump.com.
The GOP has also discussed future legislation that would allow insurers to sell across state lines and aimed to reduce litigation in healthcare, but that isnt in this bill.
However, again, that was only supposed to be phase 1 of 3, and regardless that plan didnt pass. No one knows what is coming next. With that in mind, Trump has said he generally supports it .
Here we should note that most of the good stuff cant be passed in a budget reconciliation rule, and it is, in fact, likely the Byrd rule will be used to whittle down the provisions that arent fully budget-related in the Senate.
Sorry for the long introduction, who knew healthcare could be so complicated?
Trump said, we arent going to let them die in the streets. He was talking about his plans to ensure everyone had access to care although the last plan he supported would have left 52 million on the streets.
TIP: For now the ACA is still the law of the land. With that said, one should expect a continued effort to pass provisions like those featured below in the near future.
NOTE: The current TrumpCare plan, the AHCA, has its pros and cons . See those pros and cons if you are interested.
You May Like: What Did Trump Do For Israel
Factcheck: No Massive Prices Cuts For Prescription Drugs
FactCheck by Associated Press, Aug. 3, 2020: Actually, no massive, across-the-board cuts are in the offing for drug prices.Efforts announced last month by the presidentsuch as allowing importation of medicines from countries where prices are lowertake time to roll out. It remains to be seen how much theyll move the needle on prices.Drug importation, for example, requires regulatory actions to be taken and supply chains to be established.
Trump Outlines Healthcare Plan Ensures Coverage For Pre
Sept. 24 — President Donald Trump on Thursday signed a series of executive orders to ensure medical protections for people with pre-existing conditions, prevent surprise medical bills and guarantee price transparency.
Trump signed the orders during a trip to North Carolina as he “laid out his vision” for a healthcare system he called the America First Healthcare Plan, which he said would focus on providing increased choice, lower costs and improved care.
“We will ensure the highest standard of care anywhere in the world: cutting-edge treatments, state-of-the-art medicine, groundbreaking cures and true health security for you and your loved ones,” he said.
During a call with reporters ahead of the announcement, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar said one of the executive orders would to “provide protections to ensure that Americans with pre-existing conditions regardless of whether the Affordable Care Act is unconstitutional and its protections for pre-existing conditions invalidated.”
He also said the order would direct HHS to work with Congress to pass legislation to protect patients against surprise medical bills and to investigate executive and regulatory actions that can ensure such protections if legislation is not passed by Jan. 1.
Also Check: How To Follow President Trump On Twitter