How Trump Could Replace Obamacare
Trump has not put forward a specific health care plan since his administration backed the lawsuit to scrap Obamacare. Based on what he has supported in the past, though, it could prove tough for him to come up with a plan that meets his lofty promises.
In a CNN interview Wednesday, Vice President Mike Pence’s chief of staff, Marc Short, said Trump “will be putting forward plans this year that we hope to introduce into Congress.” He did not lay out specific proposals, beyond wanting to allow consumers to buy insurance across state lines, “reduce premiums” and “provide more freedom.”
Short noted that the administration does not expect a court decision, or a need to replace Obamacare, until the summer of 2020. The Supreme Court has already upheld Obamacare twice.
Trump’s fiscal 2020 budget provides one potential road map for the White House. The administration proposed hundreds of billions of dollars in cuts to Medicaid and Medicare. It would set up Medicaid block grants to states, echoing a plan from Sens. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., and Bill Cassidy, R-La., that the CBO estimated would lead to “millions” more uninsured. The White House did not respond to a request to comment on whether the proposals outlined in the budget were its preferred plan to overhaul the health care system.
Kaiser’s Levitt doubts Trump will have an easier time crafting a replacement plan now than the GOP did in 2017.
Termination Of Aca Cost
One of the features of the ACA was a cost-sharing scheme. The federal government provided insurance companies that participated in the ACA Exchanges payments to assist these insurers in keeping premiums costs lower and to entice them to continue to participate. In 2017, with no warning to insurance companies, the Trump Administration stopped making these payments.
The Republican Argument Hinges On Such A Tortured Interpretation Of The 2017 Tax Law That The Justices Should Not Have To Give It The Time Of Day
The Supreme Court may never consider a more important case in a more precarious national moment than the one that 18 Republican states and President Donald Trump’s Justice Department have forced onto the docket this fall. Tens of millions of Americans could lose their access to health care and hundreds of millions could lose health care protections theyve never needed more, as a result of the determination to repeal the Affordable Care Act.
If the GOP is successful, the case would have us return to the days when access to health insurance is no longer guaranteed and insurance companies decide who and what to cover and how much to charge. Elements of the ACA that are part of the fabric of our country would all be gone protected coverage for preexisting conditions, a ban on lifetime coverage limits, allowing children to remain on parents plans until age 26, free preventive benefits, and requiring coverage for essential services like mental health and prescription drugs.
Such a profound case, with such a drastic and long lasting impact, should not be considered lightly at any time. This argument hinges on such a tortured interpretation of the 2017 tax law that the justices should not have to give it the time of day. The claim from the plaintiffs and supported by the Trump administration is that when Congress passed the tax cut law and zeroed out the tax penalty for refusing to buy ACA coverage, they actually instead intended to get rid of the entire ACA.
Read Also: Federal Rent Checks
American Health Care Act Of 2017American Health Care Act of 2017
|Long title||An Act to provide for reconciliation pursuant to title II of the concurrent resolution on the budget for fiscal year 2017|
The American Health Care Act of 2017 was a bill in the 115th United States Congress. The bill, which was passed by the United States House of Representatives but not by the United States Senate, would have partially repealed the Affordable Care Act .
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office projected that the AHCA would have increased the number of uninsured people by 23 million over 10 years, but would have decreased the federal budget deficit by $119 billion over the same period. Polling consistently showed that the AHCA was deeply unpopular with the American population during and after its evaluations in Congress. Business Insider stated that the AHCA was “the least popular major bill in decades”, and major medical organizations, including the American Medical Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, strongly condemned the bill and excoriated its supporters in Congress.
American Voters Respond To Health Care
Democrats paid a political price for passing the Affordable Care Act, losing control of the House of Representatives in a wave of backlash and conservative anger.
Then Republicans paid a political price for coming so close to repealing it, losing control of the House last fall, and 41% of voters said in exit polls that the most important issue facing the country was health care. Democrats bombarded swing districts with ads about health care and warnings about the threat of losing insurance market protections like the ban on insurance companies excluding people with pre-existing conditions.
At the same time, 69% of voters in 2016 said the health care system needs major changes. Those sentiments have given Democratic presidential candidates new energy to push the health care system further left, with new proposals for a public health insurance option or even a socialized health care system where the government takes over the insurance market. That debate was temporarily sidelined Tuesday as Democrats rallied around protecting the Affordable Care Act.
Don’t Miss: Americus Trumpus
Trumps Executive Action Could Erode Marketplace Built Under Obamacare
Attempts to repeal portions of the Affordable Care Act have failed in the past several months, leading President Donald Trump to issue an executive order expanding access to cheaper, less comprehensive health care plans.
The order, signed on Oct. 12, instructs federal agencies to remove certain limitations on “association health plans” and expand the availability of short-term health plans, both of which can skirt certain minimum coverage requirements included in the Affordable Care Act and state laws.
These changes will not immediately take effect federal agencies will have to figure out how to act on Trump’s directions.
The executive action orders agencies to explore ways in which the government can expand access to short-term health plans, which are available to individuals on a three-month basis and meant for people who are in-between health care coverage plans. Under the instructions, association health plans would be allowed to sell plans across state lines those plans allow small businesses to band together to create cheaper health care plans that offer fewer benefits.
The order was intended to create more options for individuals seeking health insurance and help stimulate competition among insurers. Some health policy advocates worry that it could disrupt the insurance marketplace in a way that would drive up health care costs for elderly individuals and people with medical conditions.
It will be months before changes are seen in the marketplace.
What Exactly Did Trump Do
Unlike most developed countries, the US does not have a national health system, and since Americans have the most expensive system in the world, even a hospital trip can be financially ruinous. This is why health insurance is such a necessity.
Most Americans get insurance one of three ways: through government programs for the poor and elderly called Medicaid and Medicare, through their employer, or through the online marketplaces set up by Obamas Affordable Care Act in 2010.
It is those online marketplaces that Trumps moves this week will affect.
The group using the marketplaces is dominated by small business owners and the self-employed. Marketplace plans are tightly regulated with a standard set of benefits, including maternity care, mental healthcare, and prescription drugs.
On Thursday, Trump changed that system in two ways.
First, he signed an executive order to allow health insurers to sell loosely regulated, cheap plans outside the marketplaces. These are called association health plans, and are based on the idea that small businesses should band together to get better rates from insurance companies.
Conservatives say this turns health insurance into what it should be: a financial product meant for emergencies and designed for the middle class.
Progressive groups have called these plans junk, because they are likely to have few benefits, and may not cover people when they need it most.
Also Check: How Much To Stay In Trump Tower
Trump Signs Executive Order On Obamacare Impact Unclear
On his first day in office, President Donald Trump signed an executive order that gave federal agencies broad authority to defer or delay any part of the Affordable Care Act that costs anybody any money.
More formally, the order tells agencies they can “waive, defer, grant exemptions from, or delay the implementation of any provision or requirement of the Act that would impose a fiscal burden on any State or a cost, fee, tax, penalty, or regulatory burden on individuals, families, healthcare providers, health insurers, patients, recipients of healthcare services, purchasers of health insurance, or makers of medical devices, products, or medications.”
That’s a mouthful, but what does it mean, and how far does it go to repeal Obamacare?
Larry Levitt, senior vice-president at the respected and neutral Kaiser Family Foundation, said in a series of tweets that while the impacts are unclear, it shows the administration is “moving to unwind the Affordable Care Act, but it won’t be immediate.”
Levitt added, “One sure outcome is it creates uncertainty for insurers at a critical time.”
Health care analyst Sabrina Corlette at Georgetown University echoed Levitt’s point.
“For insurers already uncertain about their future in the Affordable Care markets, the uncertainty this executive order generates doesn’t help,” Corlette said. “At a minimum they’ll have to factor it into their 2018 premiums, which are due to be filed by May 3 in most states.”
But that hasn’t happened yet.
Obama To Make Return To White House To Tout His Own Health Care Law
President Trump said it would be a win for the USA if the Supreme Court eliminates the Affordable Care Act.
Obamacare will be replaced with a MUCH better, and FAR cheaper, alternative if it is terminated in the Supreme Court. Would be a big WIN for the USA! the president said Sunday in a tweet.
The statement came as Democratic leaders Rep. Nancy Pelosi and Sen. Chuck Schumer claimed the only reason hes in a rush to get Judge Amy Coney Barrett on the bench is to kill the health-care plan.
What I am concerned about is anyone that President Trump would have appointed was there to undo the Affordable Care Act. That is why he was in such a hurry, Pelosi said on CNNs State of the Union.
The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on the Affordable Care Act on Nov. 10 one week after the election.
If Barrett clears the nomination process and is confirmed by election day Nov. 3 as the president and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell intend, she would be able to participate in the arguments over the Affordable Care Act.
Pelosi argued Americans would lose health care at a time the coronavirus pandemic has killed more than 200,000 people in the US.
Schumer, at a news conference later Sunday about Trumps court selection, said Barrett has already criticized Chief Justice John Roberts 2012 vote upholding the Affordable Care Act, and that a reading of the law should invalidate it completely.
Don’t Miss: Mary And Fred Trump In Kkk
Elimination Of The Individual Mandate
Perhaps the most significant change made to the ACA under the Trump Administration is the elimination of what is known as the individual mandate. The individual mandate was the requirement under the ACA that people lacking health insurance coverage from their employers or some other source and people who didnt qualify for Medicaid or Medicare needed to obtain coverage, usually through the ACA Exchanges. If people obliged to obtain health insurance in this manner failed to do so, they faced a penalty on their taxes. The Trump Administration took the teeth out of the individual mandate and lowered the tax penalty to $0, according to National Public Radio.
How Price Transparency Would Revolutionize Healthcare
Another Trump policy helps the chronically ill save tax-free for their health care. For example, diabetics can make deposits to their health savings accounts for the first time even if they have a plan that covers insulin before meeting their deductible. The president has also taken action to increase kidney donations and dialysis provided in patients homes rather than predominantly in hospitals and clinics.
And on pharmaceuticals, the president should tout tangible successes. Overall, drug price inflation was just 1.5 percent from 2017 to 2019, in part from a surge of competition introduced after a historic number of generic drugs were approved by the Food and Drug Administration. And the president signed the Right to Try Act, permitting very sick patients to access experimental, but potentially life-saving, treatments.
While the president certainly needs to articulate his vision for future health reform, he has a good health-care record that he can run on now and he should use the forthcoming debates to make this case.
Brian Blase is a research fellow at the Galen Institute and the Foundation for Government Accountability, and the president of Blase Policy Strategies LLC. He served as a special assistant to President Trump at the National Economic Council, 2017-19.
You May Like: How Many Times Did Trump Lie During The Debate
Fact Check: Who’s Right About Protections For Pre
After that, the president and his administration shifted to a piecemeal approach as they tried to take apart the ACA. “ObamaCare is a broken mess,” the president tweeted in the fall of 2017, after repeal in Congress had failed. “Piece by piece, we will now begin the process of giving America the great HealthCare it deserves!”
Two years later, what has his administration done to change the ACA, and who’s been affected? Below are five of the biggest changes to the federal health law under President Trump.
Secretary Of Health And Human Services Tom Price
- During an interview on March 12, 2017, NBC’s Chuck Todd asked Price if the AHCA “which leaves much of the Obamacare architecture in place, is an acknowledgement that the health care system cant be run by the free market alone.” Price replied, “No, not at all. And obviously this is a transition that we’re going through, but the important thing is to appreciate that the market as it is right now is failing. Obamacare, the ACA, has failed. Youve got premiums going up, you’ve got deductibles where people have an insurance card but they don’t have any coverage, got a third of the counties in this nation that only have one insurer offering coverage, five states with only one insurer offering coverage. That’s not a choice nor is it responsible to the individuals who are going to be selecting the coverage. So what we need to do is to fix this, to move in a direction that puts patients and families and doctors in charge of their health care, and not Washington, D.C.”
- In 2015, Price said, It needs to be fully repealed, because the first step out of the gate for Obamacare is a step in the wrong direction and that is for government control over every aspect of health care, so it’s hard to fix the system that they have put in place without ending that premise that government ought to be running and controlling health care.
Also Check: Cost Of Room At Trump Tower