Trumpcare Has Been Met With Political Resistance
Trumpcare was scheduled to be voted on by the House in March of 2017, but the bill was pulled at the last minute due to Republican fears that it would not get enough votes to pass.
After making some changes to the bill, it was brought before the House in early May of 2017, and it passed by a count of 217-213, with 20 Republicans voting against it. No Democrats voted for the bill.
The Senate declined to vote on the bill as it was and instead formed the aforementioned panel to make changes.
Trumpcare has also received opposition from a number of organizations including AARP, the American Medical Association, the American Nurses Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Hospital Association, among others.
Opposition of Trumpcare was spurred in part by a report released by the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office , which estimated that the number of uninsured people under the age of 65 would nearly double by 2026.2
Executive Order On An America
The White House, September 24, 2020
Section 1. Purpose. Since January 20, 2017, my Administration has been committed to the goal of bringing great healthcare to the American people and putting patients first.
On December 22, 2017, I signed into law the repeal of the burdensome individual-mandate penalty
Executive Order 13813 of October 12, 2017 My Administration increased the availability of renewable short-term, limited-duration healthcare plans My Administration expanded health reimbursement arrangements My Administration also issued a rule to increase the availability of association health plans
Economic Report of the President , my Administrations expansion of health savings accounts
my Administration acted to dramatically increase the accessibility and availability of telehealth services for Medicare beneficiaries
waivers allow States to move away from the ACAs rigid structure
my Administration has paved the way for a new wave of innovation to allow patients to safely send their own medical records to care providers of their choosing
CMS has acted to offer Medicare beneficiaries prescription drug plans with the option of insulin capped at $35 in out-of-pocket expenses
Executive Order 13937 of July 24, 2020 low-income Americans who receive care from a federally qualified health center will have access to insulin and injectable epinephrine at prices lower than ever before
Back To The Future: Trumps History Of Promising A Health Plan That Never Comes
Ever since he was a presidential candidate, President Donald Trump has been promising the American people a terrific, phenomenal and fantastic new health care plan to replace the Affordable Care Act.
But, in the 3½ years since he set up shop in the Oval Office, he has yet to deliver.
In his early days on the campaign trail, circa 2015, he said on CNN he would repeal Obamacare and replace it with something terrific, and on Sean Hannitys radio show he said the replacement would be something great. Fast-forward to 2020. Trump has promised an Obamacare replacement plan five times so far this year. And the plan is always said to be just a few weeks away.
Recommended Reading: What Did Donald Trump Lie About
What Would Trumpcare Look Like Follow Gops Choice And Competition Clues
Eliminating the penalty also caused insurance premiums to rise, says Sabrina Corlette, director of the Center on Health Insurance Reforms at Georgetown University. Insurance companies were getting very strong signals from the Trump administration that even if the ACA wasnt repealed, the Trump administration probably was not going to enforce the individual mandate, she says. Insurance companies figured that without a financial penalty, healthy people would opt not to buy insurance, and the pool of those that remained would be smaller and sicker.
So, even though the $0 penalty didnt actually go into effect until 2019, Corlette says, insurance companies in anticipation of the individual mandate going away and in anticipation that consumers would believe that the individual mandate was no longer going to be enforced priced for that for 2018. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, premiums went up about 32%, on average, for ACA silver plans that went into effect in early 2018, although most people received subsidies to offset those premium hikes.
Is Trump Exercising Like His Physician Recommended Despite His Apparent Hate For It
By now, it’s quite clear that the president needs to have made some serious lifestyle changes in order to ensure longevity, or at least to get him through the end of his presidency. As we already discussed, his physician recommended he institute more exercise into his daily routine. But from the sounds of it, exercise is not one of Trump’s favorite activities, despite making claims he was “always the best athlete.” In the same article that’s referenced above from the Washington Post, Jackson had said that Trump wasn’t very enthusiastic about including more exercise into his everyday schedule, but was more than willing to make necessary changes to his diet.
Just how much does the President despise exercise? Apparently, when he plays golf, a quintessential presidential sportbut a low-intensity one at thathe scoots around in his golf cart between holes instead of getting some cardio in by walking. For comparison, Business Insider had reported last year that former President Barack Obama did a 45-minute combination of weight training and cardio workout every single morning during his eight years in the White House. Similar to Trump, late President George H.W. Bush also played golf, although he added a touch of cardio to the sport by engaging in a version of the game referred to as speed golf, which entails sprinting in between holes in order to beat the opponent.
You May Like: What Kind Of Jobs Has Trump Created
Trump Promises Phenomenal Health Plan What Might That Mean
While many Capitol Hill Republicans want to avoid a repeat of the Affordable Care Act repeal debate, President Donald Trump keeps promising a health plan that will be phenomenal and make the GOP the party of health care.
Last month, Medicare chief Seema Verma said, Were actively engaged in conversations on what to do. Earlier in August, Trump adviser Kellyanne Conway indicated an announcement might come this month.
Behind the pronouncements lies a conundrum: whether to stray beyond efforts underway to improve the nations health care system loosening insurance regulations, talking about drug prices, expanding tax-free health savings accounts to develop an overarching plan.
For the White House, its a fraught decision.
Yes Trump Has A Health Care Plan He Has Been Implementing It
Donald TrumpSix big off-year elections you might be missingMeghan McCain to Trump: ‘Thanks for the publicity’MORE does not have a health care plan is flat out false.
Unfortunately, the mainstream news medias fact checkers probably wont call him out on it, and not just because of their normal anti-Trump bias. In fact, there is a widespread misunderstanding of what the president has done in health care and how it all fits together.
Back in 2018, we described President Trumps 1,000 step progress on health reform, noting that instead of opting to pass one giant, comprehensive health care bill, the president was delivering a series of small but significant reforms to cumulatively take us to a much better destination.
That destination was outlined in 2017 by the administration in a 124-page Health and Human Services document, Reforming Americas Healthcare System Through Choice and Competition. The document is a distillation of the dysfunction of our health care system, much of which ObamaCare made worse. It also paints a picture of an alternative model one that puts patients before insurance companies or government bureaucrats and delivers better care and coverage at lower costs.
Everything that President Trump has done in health care since then has been consistent with the vision laid out in the document. The challenge for the news media, and even some of the presidents supporters, has been an issue of attention span a tendency to miss the forest for the trees.
Read Also: Cost To Stay At Trump Hotel
Trump’s Changes To Obamacare Would Likely Be Quite Minor In A Second Term
To get an idea for what Trump might do next, it’s worth looking at how his administration has already changed the ACA since he took office.
In 2017, Trump and Republicans in Congress zeroed out the Obama-era mandate on coverage, allowing Americans to once again go insurance-free, without risking penalties. Many Democrats lamented the move, arguing it would make the health insurance marketplace more unstable, by taking more healthy people out of the system. But the truth is that ACA coverage was already unaffordable for many people making over $50,000 .
“The ACA was more focused on sicker and lower income populations, and trying to really provide care for underserved populations,” Fann said.
The Trump administration has also allowed more people to buy insurance that falls outside of the ACA’s original rules. For instance, people are allowed to sign up for short-term health insurance plans, which don’t have to cover people with pre-existing conditions. The plans have been derided by Democrats as “junk insurance,” but Trump officials say they give some level of coverage to people who can’t afford ACA plans, who would otherwise be uninsured.
“I would say the Republican plan is more of broader tax credits, trying to attract more people,” Fann said.
“Insurers are coming back to the market, premiums are declining,” he said.
“If we leave the ACA alone, it’s going to continue to get better,” Fann said. “Let’s just leave this thing alone until we understand what’s going on.”
The Cost Of Trumpcare
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget did a review of Trumps healthcare plan. The following article shows a breakdown of costs: MEASURING TRUMPS HEALTHCARE PLAN. The result is a cost of roughly $550 billion over ten years under conventional scoring and about $330 billion with dynamic scoring .
Note that this analysis does not include Mr. Trumps call to negotiate aggressively for Medicare drugs, a policy that is not listed on his website. He has previously claimed that $300 billion a year could be saved through negotiation, a claim we rated as false because Medicare will only spend an average of $111 billion each year on prescription drugs. Based on previous estimates by CBO, actual savings would likely be small or negligible.
NOTE: The plan assumes a full repeal of ObamaCare before replacing it. While this is possible given Trumps statements, it isnt necessarily what we would get from the future President Trump.
NOTE: Like him or hate him, Trump has mentioned some critical health policies like expanding Medicaid and debating drug costs for Medicare. These didnt make it into the Trump plan as written, but it would be a mistake to overlook the benefits of strategies like debating drug prices for Medicare.
|10-Year Estimates of Healthcare Reform to Make America Great Again|
You May Like: Trumps Lies To Date
Trumpcare As Found On Donaldjtrumpcom Compared To The Healthcare Bills Passed In The House And Senate
NOTE: Keep in mind things are changing rapidly, so everything below is subject to change.
The following is a short version of Trumps plan on his website , the sections in red have not been addressed yet.
In other words, most of what Trump promised didnt make it into phase 1 of the American HealthCare Act/Better Care Reconciliation Act, or the new rules, with the exception of a few items like repealing the mandates fee and beefing up HSAs.
NOTE: There has been many, many attempted and actual changes to the Affordable Care Act during Trumps time in office. The repeal and replace plans did not pass, but many changes did occur . This page focuses on what Trump promised on his site and the repeal and replace plans. See the links above for the orders and HHS changes, well work on weaving them into here shortly. With that said, many planks from the bills got done via orders and HHS, and another repeal and replace plan with similar provisions is likely, so the rest is worth a read from that perspective.
Donald Trump’s Health Care Policies The Balance
Replace the ACA with a better health care plan. He continued to promise it but has not delivered. Keep existing Medicare and Social Security benefits intact. While on the campaign trail in 2016, Trump promised he wouldn’t touch Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. These benefits are part of the mandatory budget.
Also Check: Jobs Created Under Trump
Us Faces A Child Care Emergency Biden Says In Unveiling $775 Billion Plan
On abortion access, Biden is in favor of restoring funding for Planned Parenthood. He does not support the so-called gag rule or the Hyde Amendment, which bans most federal funding for abortions. Biden backed the Hyde Amendment for a significant portion of his career and only came out against the legislation in July 2019, saying he could no longer support an amendment that makes that right dependent on someones ZIP code.
Biden also wants to allocate $775 billion toward a plan for child and elder care. A lot of the funding would go toward cutting Medicaid waitlists for people needing home and community care, and to provide tax breaks to people who care for older family members.
Biden also pledges to invest in further health care employment, training 35,000 workers on how to aid Americans suffering from opioid addictions and adding tens of thousands of new jobs caring for veterans.
Biden also calls for the creation of a public health jobs corps, which would employ more than 100,000 Americans as health care workers in medically underserved communities to work in disease prevention.
Recommended Reading: What Is The Approval Rating For Trump
An Introduction To The Many Healthcare Bills Regulations And Ideas We Call Trumpcare
Below we explain different aspects of TrumpCare.
When people say TrumpCare they are essentially referring to healthcare changes made, attempted to be made, and/or pushed for under President Trump . This is sort of like how when people say ObamaCare they are referring to changes to the healthcare system under Obama, but especially the Affordable Care Act.
Changes and policy ideas under Trump that may be considered TrumpCare have included:
- PROPOSED: Trump has said he will pass executive orders to protect pre-existing conditions which would be repealed by the lawsuit backed by his administration along with the rest of the ACA. The specifics of these orders are not known yet.
- PROPOSED: The 2021 budget which includes almost $1 trillion in cuts to Medicaid and the ACA and $600 billion savings from Medicare.
- LIST OF GOALS: The TrumpCare as presented on DonaldJTrump.com , and
- LIST OF GOALS: Past promises Trump has made .
In other words, TrumpCare is a term that describes the ongoing health care reform effort under Donald Trump .
This is somewhat complicated by the fact that a repeal and replace plan did not pass Congress, and instead the Trump administration has been gradually reshaping the healthcare system using executive orders, legislative action, action in congress, and changes done via federal agencies like HHS.
Read Also: Who Is Older Biden Or Trump
Recommended Reading: How Much Does A Night At The Trump Hotel Cost